Depth Is the Test That Matters Now

Reading Time
5 min
Article Sections
6
Share Links
3
On This Page
Article Section
A Scope 3 emissions figure that cannot be broken into its component parts is not evidence of transparency. It is evidence of an unfinished disclosure. Yet that is what roughly 96% of India's Scope 3 reporters currently offer investors, assurers and regulators.
Awareness of carbon reporting has genuinely grown across Indian boardrooms in the past two years. ICRA ESG Ratings recorded a roughly 59% year-on-year rise in Scope 3 disclosure among India's top 200 listed companies, and separate research tracking BRSR reporting broadly has documented steadily expanding energy and emissions disclosure coverage. That momentum is real and deserves to be acknowledged rather than dismissed.
But awareness is not the same as depth, and Climes' 2026 research shows the two have decoupled: Scope 1 and Scope 2 disclosure at 86.8% against category-level Scope 3 disclosure of just 1.5%. Rising awareness should be treated as reason to move faster on Scope 3 depth, not as evidence the job is already underway.
Article Section
SEBI's BRSR framework covers the top 1,000 listed companies by market capitalisation, with a subset of nine attributes under BRSR Core carrying a phased assurance requirement that reaches the full top 1,000 entities in FY2026-27. Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions were specified tightly from the outset; Scope 3 has so far required only assessment rather than assurance, which is the structural reason the two numbers have moved so differently.
One view holds that this gap is reasonable. Scope 3 measurement genuinely is more complex than Scope 1 or 2, spanning fifteen GHG Protocol categories across an entire value chain, and regulators elsewhere have hesitated over the same complexity: Scope 3 disclosure was proposed and then dropped from the SEC's own climate rule on measurement-cost grounds. A company waiting for SEBI or the RBI to specify Scope 3 category reporting more precisely before investing heavily is not being negligent, it is being proportionate.
The opposing view points to the nineteen companies already reporting Scope 3 by category, several of them outside the largest IT and pharma names, as evidence that the barrier is organisational priority as much as technical difficulty. India's RBI has also already extended Scope 3 expectations into its climate-risk framework for select financial institutions, even without a finalised assurance requirement, suggesting regulatory direction is already visible for those willing to read it.
Article Section
Scope 3 spans fifteen categories across an entire value chain, and companies reasonably point to measurement complexity as a reason for slower progress, particularly for category 11 use-phase emissions in automobiles or category 1 purchased-goods emissions in textiles. But nineteen Indian companies already report ten or more categories, and they are not confined to the largest, best-resourced names. That is enough to show the barrier is organisational priority as much as it is technical difficulty.
BRSR Core reasonable assurance already extends to the top 1,000 listed entities in FY2026-27, and CBAM's first declaration covering 2026 imports is due on 30 September 2027. Companies that treat Scope 3 depth as a future problem will be building supplier-level data and audit trails under an assurance deadline rather than ahead of one, which is a materially harder position to work from.
Textiles discloses Scope 3 at less than a third of the rate recorded in steel and metals, despite carrying some of the highest exposure to European buyer due diligence requirements. Automobiles disclose Scope 3 at 50.0% but confirm assurance at only 10.0%, a mismatch between reporting and evidence that will draw scrutiny once assurance moves from voluntary to mandatory.
Article Section
Companies can begin mapping existing Scope 3 totals into GHG Protocol categories using data they already hold in procurement and logistics systems, rather than waiting for an assurance provider to request it later.
The nineteen companies with category-level disclosure got there by building recurring supplier and logistics data pipelines, a decision that pays off across financing, buyer relationships and assurance cycles at the same time.
Textiles and chemicals companies exposed to CBAM and buyer due diligence can look to steel and metals, where Scope 3 disclosure already reaches 54.2%, for a workable template rather than starting from first principles.
Article Section
The direction of travel in Indian carbon disclosure is genuinely encouraging, but the Climes findings are a reminder that awareness and depth are different achievements, and only one of them is currently being delivered at scale.
The companies that close that gap before assurance and CBAM deadlines converge will spend the next two reporting cycles refining their numbers. The companies that wait will spend them rebuilding.
Article Section
Yes, independent research recording a roughly 59% year-on-year rise in Scope 3 disclosure among India's top 200 listed companies points to genuine momentum.
Because BRSR specifies Scope 1 and Scope 2 tightly while leaving the Scope 3 format largely open, so most companies report a total without the category structure underneath it.
It risks facing supplier-data and audit-trail requirements under assurance and CBAM deadlines rather than building them on its own timeline.
Nineteen Indian listed companies, including Infosys, Wipro, Apollo Tyres and Adani Energy Solutions, already disclose Scope 3 by GHG Protocol category.
Textiles and chemicals, given their high exposure to CBAM and buyer due diligence alongside comparatively low Scope 3 and assurance disclosure rates.
Keep Reading

Steel, Aluminium, Cement, Fertilisers, Manufacturing
CBAM's definitive phase began on January 1, 2026. For Indian exporters, that means real financial exposure, not just reporting.
Read more
All Industries
What Every Listed Company Must Do Now?
Read more
All Industries
Why Is It Reshaping Global Energy Policy?
Read moreNext Step
Talk to ESG Astraa about disclosures, climate strategy, governance controls, and execution support for your team.
We use cookies to run this site and, with your consent, to understand how it is used. See our Cookie Policy for details.